STEELERS RB REDMAN READY TO CARRY HEAVY LOAD NFL UNION FILES SUIT AGAINST LEAGUE OVER 2010 CAP BRONCOS TRADE FOR CHRIS GRONKOWSKI 49ERS SIGN ALL-PRO PUNTER ANDY LEE THROUGH 2018 TITANS AGREE TO TERMS WITH THOMPSON, SOLOMON VIKINGS SIGN 4TH-ROUND DRAFT PICK RHETT ELLISON TUESDAY'S SPORTS IN BRIEF NFL MAKING THIGH AND KNEE PADS MANDATORY IN '13 TEXANS REBUILDING O-LINE AFTER DEPARTURES SOME NEW FACES FOR PACKERS
TOP STORIES BLOG SOTL NEWS
FORGOT PASSWORD
KEEP ME LOGGED IN
NFL PLAYER FEED FIND NFL PLAYERS
VIEW ALL TEAMS AT A GLANCE
INJURY REPORT TRANSACTIONS STANDINGS
LEADERS
BY TEAM BY PLAYER
BLOG
GET STARTED SELECT TRAINING COACH MOM & DAD
FEATURED NFLPA.TV HOT THIS WEEK MOST VIEWED HIGHEST RATED MOST COMMENTS COACH MOM & DAD HEALTH & SAFETY
NFL GEAR SOTL GEAR
VIEW MORE RESULTS FOR
SELECT A CHANNEL
SELECT A CHANNEL

Team

Blog

Detroit Lions Scoreboard

Detroit Lions 28 @ New Orleans Saints 45 Final

  • Detroit Lions's Schedule
  • Detroit Lions's Clubhouse
  • Detroit Lions's Team Stats
  • Detroit Lions's Team Roster
  • Detroit Lions's Team Blog by D. Barnsdale
Click To View
Click To View
Click To View
Click To View
View
Here
Stats And Team Logos Provided And Licensed By STATS, INC.
TEAM BLOGGER
NEW ORLEANS
45
2
DETROIT
28
1
00:00
F
---
---
---
SPORTSBLOG.com

Derrick Barnsdale

Still waiting for that Lions playoff run...

I am a huge life long Detroit Lions fan. I have written off and on about the team through my strugglingsportsreporter.com blog since 1997. I believe I have an interesting take on the team from my years of indentured "fan"-itude. I have ridden the ups and downs (mostly downs) of the team my entire life. I can t (...)

For all media requests, speaking engagements: Lions@sportsblog.com

Holding? The NFL should drop it.

Posted By Derrick Barnsdale

2/6/2012 10:39AM

Hey NFL, why don't you just admit that nobody knows how or when or maybe even why to call a holding penalty? It's a farce. The only logical thing to do is either drop it as a penalty or admit that the NFL and the referees have a free hand in determining who they want to win any game played.

Seriously, the refs cannot EVER call it consistently.

In the playoffs this year the the lack of holding calls has been prominent, especially in a league that has mostly forsaken the run game for the passing game. If teams are passing upwards of 50 times a game, where are all the holding calls? How are we watching legitimately fair games played by the rules if the refs are cherry-picking when they call "Holding?" It begs the question, "Are these games on the level?"

Over the last 20-30 years the league has consistently done everything in it's power to increase scoring and the excitement of the passing game...so why don't they just go that extra step, quit the charade and just strike "Holding" from the rule books? They're not calling it anyway, and they're certainly not calling it fairly...so why allow there to be any lingering doubt over the legitimacy of the game?

Striking holding will allow for much more fervent and effective protection of the million dollar QB assets that the league has also blitzkrieg'ed rule after rule to protect. Furthermore, it'll allow for more time in the pocket, allowing for more completed passes, and more scoring...the Holy Grail for TV ratings and a large percentage of fans.

The way it is called now is not fair, if you're not going to be fair, be not fair to everybody...that's somehow...kind of...fair?

Frankly, throwing out holding will penalize teams that have been built on defense, which will further the road down offense only football...which is really what the league seems to want. Maybe someday soon the league will get rid of defense all together and...then get rid of the offensive lineman, because obviously you won't need them anymore...just quarterbacks and receivers...but they can get rid of receivers too if they just put targets out on the field...then it'll just be quarterbacks...and the scoring will go crazy and...yeah...you're right, that's stupid...but then so is only calling a very debilitating penalty when the refs feel like it.

Tags : PENALTIES • nfl • nfl • RULES • NFL
Top tagged
  • TIMTEBOW
  • OF
  • PEYTONMANNING
  • THE
  • SCHOOL
Categories
Archive
  • April 2012
  • March 2012
  • February 2012
  • January 2012
  • December 2011

Recent comments

Hell yea

By Michelle Fairchild

NFL Draft 2012: A New Era for the National Football League

Wtf????

By ilka ortiz

NFL Draft 2012: A New Era for the National Football League

Ayo

By join hnnu

NFL Draft 2012: A New Era for the National Football League

    • NEWS
    • TOP STORIES
    • SOTL NEWS
    • BLOG
    • ABOUT
    • OUR STORY
    • THE TEAM
    • CONTACT US
    • MOBILE
    • iPHONE/iPAD
    • ANDROID
    • CONNECT
    • REFER A FRIEND
    • FACEBOOK
    • TWITTER
    • MISC
    • FAQS
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • REFUND POLICY
    • GET INVOLVED
    • ARE YOU A SPORTS WRITER?
    • AFFILIATE PROGRAM
    • REFERRAL PROGRAM
    • ADVERTISE WITH US
    • CREATE AN AD
    • DOWNLOAD MEDIA KIT
    • BRAND CAMPAIGNS
Visit Our Twitter Feed

@TWITTER More from @WesWelker's @ProCamps. Wes picks the winner of an @SOTLNFL all-access training pack. http://t...
view more »

Visit Our YouTube Premium Channel
Visit Our Facebook Page

FACEBOOK DRAWING AT 5pm EST TODAY...SO LOG IN & POST NOW! Win a football signed by two Pro Bowlers! Go to SOTL and post on...
view more »

NFL PLAYERS, INC.

OFFICIALLY LICENSED PARTNER OF NFL PLAYERS INC.

© 2012 School of the Legends, LLC., All Rights Reserved.

VERSION 2.0 TERMS RULES PARTNERS